Is this a good trade?

It's not a bad trade. You say you've got ian Kinsler at 2B and you can afford to give up Manny. If you need a third baseman, A. Ramirez is a good choice. I'm just not huge on paying for saves. Closers are overrated. Just look at what George Sherrill is doing in B-More. I probably wouldn't do this trade, but if you feel you're getting a good deal, pull the trigger. Let's hope you're not shooting yourself in the foot.